Alto Street

Alto Street is several blocks from Santa Fe’s famous Oldest House Museum, but to understand the street’s history, you must also understand the Oldest House’s history. Between the 1600s and 1800s, the Oldest House was home to two sisters believed to be witches. Though often tried as criminals, they had the favor of local politicians who sought their potions for success. One night, a young man named Juan Espinoza came seeking a powerful love potion, leading to events that spiraled out of control.

Juan Espinoza came to the sisters for a love potion to feed his paramour, but the woman fell in love with Juan’s brother instead. Furious, Juan demanded a refund. The interaction turned hostile, and the sisters sliced his head off with Juan’s sword. Today, a headless horseman travels along Alto Street, several blocks from the Oldest House. This mysterious traveler is believed to be Juan Espinoza, still seeking revenge.